Power Plays
The devil, as always, is in the details as UCLA scientists and engineers participate in an international effort to harness the power of the sun

By Bruce Schecter

“Nuclear fusion,” Mohamed Abdou, codirector of UCLA’s Institute of Plasma and Fusion Research, likes to point out, “was discovered long before fission.” Walk out on a sunny day, he observes, and you are basking in the warmth and light created by fusion taking place in our home star. In contrast with nuclear fission, however, whose energy scientists were harnessing within a decade of its discovery in the late 1930s, fusion energy, which will essentially use seawater as fuel, is still a dream -- a dream that scientists around the world, including several from UCLA, are energetically pursuing.
The urgency of the scientists’ pursuit is driven by their awareness of our planet’s rapidly dwindling stockpile of fossil fuel. Estimates of how long coal and oil will continue to serve as the world’s principal sources of energy vary widely. An increasing world population, accelerating rates of energy consumption and our high tolerance for the damage to the environment caused by the burning of fossil fuels are some of the variables that must be taken into account. A good ballpark estimate is that in something like 100 years we will have burned up our prehistoric energy legacy.
Renewable resources such as solar, wind and wave power will help compensate for the loss, but with a world population estimated at 11 billion by the year 2100, such sources will not supply nearly enough energy to satisfy demand. Fission power plants, with their susceptibility to catastrophic accidents, their hazardous, long lived wastes and their dependence on a finite stockpile of uranium, will inevitably multiply. That is, until safe, commercial fusion power plants begin to supply the world with affordable, virtually inexhaustible energy -- perhaps in the early decades of the next century.
Nuclear fusion is the purest realization of Albert Einstein’s equation of mass and energy. In a fusion power plant, nuclei of deuterium and tritium (two isotopes of hydrogen that may be extracted from seawater) fuse to make helium. The combined weight of a deuterium nucleus and a tritium nucleus exceeds the weight of the resulting nucleus of helium. The difference in mass, as predicted by Einstein’s famous equation, is converted into energy -- the energy that powers the sun and the stars, the energy of a hydrogen bomb, the energy scientists have been trying to domesticate for more than four decades.
Thermonuclear fusion has been difficult to achieve and control because its fuel must burn at tremendously high temperatures. The deuterium and tritium in a power plant must be heated to 100 million degrees Celsius (10 times the temperature of the sun’s interior) if they are to fuse. The sun burns a different fuel, a mixture of hydrogen and helium, that gives off energy at a rate of only about two watts of power per ton -- far too low to be useful as an energy source on Earth. (A ton of hamsters running on treadmills generates far more energy.) The sun makes up for this paltry output by its sheer mass, an attribute that researchers on Earth cannot imitate.
At the temperatures required for fusion, the electrons that orbit atomic nuclei are stripped away. The result is a new state of matter, called a plasma, a swirling, overheated mass of negatively charged electrons and positively charged nuclei. The challenge of fusion energy is to find a way to hold this astronomically hot plasma as it burns, to find a bottle that can hold a star.
No material bottle will work, of course. And even if a material could be found that did not vaporize under such intense heat, the plasma would cool as it came into contact with the bottle walls, quickly dousing the fusion reaction. One possible solution, pursued by researchers for more than 40 years, is to build a bottle without walls, or at least not walls made from matter. Such a container would take advantage of the fact that a plasma consists of electrically charged particles, and that electrically charged particles can be manipulated by a magnetic field. The weaving of such bottles out of magnetic fields (called magnetic confinement) has proven to be an extremely challenging scientific and technological problem.
The most promising approach has been a device known as a tokamak, in which the plasma is confined to a donut shaped (torroidal, in the jargon of topology) magnetic field.
With the aid of tokamaks, scientists discovered that plasmas are far more difficult to handle than they ever imagined. (A plasma confined in a tokamak writhes and bends in the magnetic field, becomes as turbulent as white water rapids and soon splashes out of the bottle.) Nevertheless, after decades of research at laboratories around the world, enough progress has been made that scientists are now confident that tokamak fusion reactors will someday work.
Scientists and engineers from Europe, Japan, Russia and the United States have embarked on an unprecedented international collaboration to investigate how such breakthroughs in fusion technology can be translated into a working power plant. The project, known as the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER), is planned for completion in 2010 at a cost of around $10 billion, hence the need for international cooperation. UCLA scientists are deeply involved in the planning of this massive project.
Finally, after years of speculation and research, scientists are confident that they will be able to achieve and control the release of fusion energy. Exactly when the first economically feasible fusion plants will go on-line is still an open question. Meanwhile, an assortment of scientists and engineers at UCLA are hard at work to ensure that the power of fusion will be available when we need it.


Power Plays...
The Electric Tokamak The Numerical Tokamak Laser Fusion
Advanced Technology and Materials Outer Space in a Bottle


CHALLENGE - Spring 1997 || CHALLENGE MAGAZINE || RESEARCH@UCLA